ADR-0061: SEU may pay the rollup's fee; SOL always can

Two kinds of Solieum chain exist, and today each has one gas asset: The node refuses a chain with both a native coin and a portal (chain.rs:533): bridged SOL…

Status: accepted. Dated 2026-11-17.

Status: accepted, 2026-11-17. Decided by the owner, who asked whether a chain could take its gas fees in SEU and still bridge SOL, was given two ways, and chose this one ("yes option 1"), then set the discount at 25% ("yes 25% discount"). Design only: nothing here is built, compiled or deployed, and no chain changes today. It reopens ADR-0017 §2.1 and ADR-0018 §2b rule 1, as ADR-0018 §6 says any proposal that puts the coin in the fee path must, and amends ADR-0025 §3's rule 1 to match.

1. Context

Two kinds of Solieum chain exist, and today each has one gas asset:

ChainGasBridge to SolanaExample
The rollupSOL, bridged in through the portalYesthe testnet (6666) and mainnet (2222) as planned
A coin chain (ADR-0025)SEU, the chain's native coinNo: anchored onlythe devnet, 7792

The node refuses a chain with both a native coin and a portal (chain.rs:533): bridged SOL and the native coin would share one balance, the lamport balance every account has. So a chain cannot take SEU as gas and still let SOL in, as things are built.

The owner asked for both. There are two ways:

  1. SOL stays the gas, and SEU may pay the fee instead, at a discount. SOL arrives through the portal exactly as today; SEU arrives as a token through the portal's token path; a transaction may pay its fee in either.
  2. SEU becomes the only gas, and bridged SOL becomes a token (wrapped SOL), as "custom gas token" layer 2s do on Ethereum. A user who bridges SOL in cannot send anything until they also hold SEU.

This record takes the first. It is the Starknet-style option the project reserved on 2026-09-02 (TOKEN-IDEA.md) and withdrew on 2026-09-05 (ADR-0017 §2.1, ADR-0018 §2b rule 1). The owner reinstates it here, in the narrower form below.

What exists today, so nothing is assumed:

  • The fee: a flat 5,000 lamports a transaction, or whatever a genesis names (fees::flat_fee), kept and credited to the sequencer the genesis names (ADR-0017 §2.2, fees::fee_kept_from). One step, two leaves: payer minus the fee, sequencer plus the fee.
  • The portal's token path: deposit_token, prove_token_withdrawal, finalize_token_withdrawal and per-mint limits are in the program.
  • The node's token path: absent. A deposit record carries no mint (l1.rs, DepositRecord) and the node has no token withdrawal leaf, so the chain side of token bridging has to be built (§5.1).

2. Decision

On the rollup, SOL stays the gas and always works. A transaction may instead pay its base fee in SEU, at a discount. Nobody ever needs SEU to use the rollup.

  1. SOL is the default and is never refused. Every transaction can pay in SOL, at the SOL fee, on every chain this record touches. A wallet that knows nothing about SEU keeps working unchanged.
  2. SEU is opt-in, per transaction. The transaction says which asset pays its fee. If it names SEU and the payer's SEU balance cannot cover the fee, the transaction is refused at admission, exactly as an unfunded SOL fee is; it is never silently charged in SOL instead.
  3. Only the base fee. Priority bids (ADR-0017 §2.5), bridge costs and every bond stay SOL. ADR-0018 rule 2 is unchanged: no bond that secures user funds or pays a challenger is ever SEU.
  4. One mint. The only SEU accepted is the canonical mint, bridged through the portal's token path. The chain names that mint once (its genesis, or a state value set the same way as §2.5's), and no other token pays a fee, whatever it calls itself.
  5. The SEU fee is a value in the chain's state, not a price read at execution. The SEU amount a transaction pays is stored on the chain and changed only by a parameter transaction, effective from a later block, so every node and every verifier charges the same amount from the same state. Each change moves the amount by a bounded step, so no single update can jump the fee. It is set from a time-weighted SEU/SOL price so that the SEU fee is worth the SOL fee less the discount. One function computes it, shared by the charge, the RPC fee quote and the explorer, as fees::flat_fee is for SOL today.
  6. The discount is 25%, governed inside a band of 0% to 50%. The owner set 25% to start: the SEU fee is worth three quarters of the SOL fee. Governance (ADR-0018 §2a, "the fee schedule's economic knobs") may move it within the band. The SEU fee is never worth more than the SOL fee, so paying in SEU is never a penalty. Until the vote program exists, the operator sets it, and every change is published before the block it takes effect from (§2.5).
  7. The option can be paused, forward only. The same parameter transaction can stop accepting SEU from a later block, announced in advance. Transactions already in a block are never re-charged.
  8. Where SEU fees go. Credited on the rollup to a fee account the genesis names, then moved to the settlement rewards pool (ADR-0028 §2b). Not burned, and not sold for SOL by the protocol: the same rule as the treasury's purchases (ADR-0028 §2c rule 3).

3. What it costs, and who carries it

An SEU-paid fee brings in no SOL, while the chain's Solana costs (rent, data, signatures; ADR-0017 §1, ADR-0026) stay in SOL. Every SEU-paid fee is SOL revenue the chain does not receive, and the discount widens that gap. This is the price of the option, and the treasury carries it. It is why the discount is governed, why the SEU fee is never worth more than the SOL fee (a band with a floor, not an open lever), and why §2.7 can pause it when a chain's SOL revenue stops covering its Solana costs.

4. Where it applies

NetworkSOL feeSEU fee option
Devnet coin chains (7792 and others)—Unchanged. SEU is their native gas (ADR-0025); they have no portal.
Testnet (6666)YesBuilt and demonstrated here first, with a test mint created on the Solana cluster the testnet settles to, and named as a test mint everywhere. It is never presented as SEU's address: until issuance, every address claiming to be SEU is a scam (ADR-0028 §2).
Mainnet (2222)Yes, from launchOnly after §5 is complete: SEU issued on Solana mainnet (ADR-0018 §4, ADR-0028), the token bridge built and audited, and the new fee step audited. Mainnet launches on SOL alone.

5. What has to be built, in order

  1. The token bridge on the chain side. A deposit record that carries its mint (a new record version), an SPL token credit on deposit, a token withdrawal leaf, and a refund instruction for token deposits in the portal, so a deposited token can always come back. Per-mint limits (D5) and the guardian pause cover it before any token moves (proposal-anchoring-and-bridging-2026-09-18.md §6).
  2. The SPL Token program committed in the rollup's genesis (ADR-0019), and the accepted SEU mint named there.
  3. The fee-asset field in the transaction envelope, the admission rule of §2.2, and the parameter transaction of §2.5–§2.7.
  4. The SEU fee step in the dispute game. Payer's SEU account minus the fee, fee account plus the fee: a token-account step beside today's lamport one. It is a new leaf shape, so it lands as a new commitment version with its own harness pairs and a redeploy of the game, at a block boundary the operator names (the same path ADR-0017 §5 took).
  5. Wallets, RPC and explorer. A fee quote in both assets, the asset actually paid shown on every transaction, and the SEU fee and discount readable from the chain.
  6. An external audit of items 1 and 4 before mainnet.

6. Consequences

  • ADR-0017 §2.1 now reads: the fee path is SOL by default and always; SEU may pay the base fee at a governed discount; nothing in the fee path ever requires SEU. ADR-0017's map (§3) gains one row: "base fee, paid optionally: SEU, at a discount, never required".
  • ADR-0018 §2b rule 1 now reads: no required fee-path role. The promise the rule exists to make, that a user never needs the coin to use the chain, stands. Rules 2 and 3 are unchanged.
  • ADR-0025 §3 now reads: the coin is never required in the rollup's fee path. Its role table (§2) gains "an optional way to pay the rollup's base fee".
  • The site's wording changed with this record, published on 2026-11-17: /token, the FAQ, the white paper and the investor deck no longer say "never in the rollup's fee path"; they say SOL always pays and SEU will be able to pay the base fee at a 25% discount.
  • Counsel. A fee discount for paying in the coin is a utility point that belongs in the review ADR-0028 §4 already asks for, before the option goes live on mainnet.
  • Nothing on-chain changes today. No chain, program or node is touched by this record.

7. Why this way rather than the alternatives

SEU as the only gas, SOL as a token (the second way) puts a swap before every new user's first transaction: bridge SOL in, then find SEU, then transact. That is the cost TOKEN-IDEA.md named in 2026-09 and ADR-0017 §2.6 refused at the bridge, and it would make the rollup's usability depend on SEU's liquidity on day one. It also changes the balance model of every account and every bridge step, not one fee step.

Leaving the fee path SOL only (ADR-0017 as written) was the standing decision. The owner chose to give SEU a role on the rollup that holders can use every day. This record does that without taking anything from a user who never holds SEU.

A price oracle read during execution was rejected: a fee that depends on an outside price at the moment of execution is not reproducible by a verifier replaying the block later, and the dispute game needs every step to be. A state value, changed in bounded steps, is.

8. What this does not decide

  • The update rule's exact limits: how often the SEU fee may change, by how much per change, and the price window it is set from.
  • Whether priority bids may ever be paid in SEU. Not in this record.
  • The token bridge's own design beyond what §5.1 requires: it gets its own ADR, as ADR-0028 §4 already says for the bridge that carries SEU to Solieum's own chains.